{"id":81399,"date":"2024-06-09T08:29:29","date_gmt":"2024-06-09T13:29:29","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/?p=81399"},"modified":"2024-06-09T08:29:29","modified_gmt":"2024-06-09T13:29:29","slug":"op-ed-bring-them-home-means-different-things-to-israelis-and-american-jews","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/op-ed-bring-them-home-means-different-things-to-israelis-and-american-jews\/","title":{"rendered":"OP-ED: \u2018Bring them home\u2019 means different things to Israelis and American Jews"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>By ANDREW SILOW-CARROLL<\/p>\n<p>(JTA) \u2014 Last Sunday in New York, thousands marched in the annual pro-Israel parade, less a celebration this year than a rally for the hostages held by Hamas since Oct. 7. The parade\u2019s sponsor, New York\u2019s Jewish Community Relations Council, said its goal was \u201csending an urgent message to the world: \u2018Bring Them Home Now!\u2019\u201d \u2014 raising awareness of the plight of the captives, without calling for specific actions to free them.<\/p>\n<div id=\"attachment_81400\" style=\"width: 310px\" class=\"wp-caption alignleft\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade.jpg\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-81400\" class=\"wp-image-81400 size-medium lazyload\" data-src=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade-300x167.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"300\" height=\"167\" data-srcset=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade-300x167.jpg 300w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade-1024x569.jpg 1024w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade-768x427.jpg 768w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade.jpg 1080w\" data-sizes=\"(max-width: 300px) 100vw, 300px\" src=\"data:image\/gif;base64,R0lGODlhAQABAAAAACH5BAEKAAEALAAAAAABAAEAAAICTAEAOw==\" style=\"--smush-placeholder-width: 300px; --smush-placeholder-aspect-ratio: 300\/167;\" \/><noscript><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-81400\" class=\"wp-image-81400 size-medium\" src=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade-300x167.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"300\" height=\"167\" srcset=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade-300x167.jpg 300w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade-1024x569.jpg 1024w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade-768x427.jpg 768w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-NY-Israel-Parade.jpg 1080w\" sizes=\"(max-width: 300px) 100vw, 300px\" \/><\/noscript><\/a><\/p>\n<p id=\"caption-attachment-81400\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Marchers call for the release of hostages in Gaza at the annual Israel parade in New York City, June 2, 2024. (Courtesy JCRC-NY)<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<p>By contrast, the day before, tens of thousands of protesters in Tel Aviv called on the government to strike a deal with Hamas for a ceasefire in the eight-month war in exchange for the return of the 120 remaining hostages, living and dead. Coupled with calls for the dismissal of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and for early elections, the rally in Israel was sharply political and specific in its demands.&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>One of the Israeli rally\u2019s organizers, \u201cWe Are All Hostages,\u201d this past week wrote an open letter to \u201cAmerican Jewish Organizations\u201d asking them to demand that Netanyahu accept a hostage release deal and end the war. \u201cPlease, do not remain silent in the face of his criminal abandonment of Israeli citizens in captivity,\u201d the group wrote. \u201cDo not allow him to sabotage this deal.\u201d&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>The two rallies and competing messages demonstrate a divide between many American Jews and Israelis, both marching under the banner of \u201cfree the hostages.\u201d In Israel, many if not most advocates for the hostages have been vocal in criticizing their government and calling for a ceasefire; in the United States, Jewish groups and individuals have been invoking the hostages either in apolitical gestures of solidarity, or to defend the aims of the war.&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>\u201cIt\u2019s really clear that in Israel \u2018bring them home\u2019 is directed at the government,\u201d said Rabbi Jill Jacobs, CEO of the liberal human rights group T\u2019ruah, who has written on the subject after attending a number of the rallies on visits to Israel. \u201cAmong U.S. Jews, there seems to be a belief that \u2018bring them home\u2019 is directed at everyone but Israel.\u201d&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>Saturday\u2019s dramatic rescue by the Israeli army of four hostages briefly confounded the divide. But even as Israelis celebrated in the streets and, in the case of war cabinet member Benny Gantz, tabled efforts to pressure Netanyahu on the war, many emphasized that a ceasefire deal remained the most likely way for hostages to come home. \u201cUntil today 7 hostages have been rescued in military operations. Over 100 hostages were returned in a ceasefire deal,\u201d tweeted Maoz Inon, an entrepreneur whose parents were killed on Oct. 7 and has emerged as a leading anti-war activist. \u201cThe only way forward is ending the war and reaching a deal.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>The contrast in messaging is captured in an ubiquitous symbol of the \u201cfree the hostages\u201d movement: replica dog tags with either the names of captives or messages of solidarity. American Jews have been wearing them since shortly after Oct. 7, the way a previous generation wore bracelets for Vietnam War P.O.W.\u2019s or Soviet Jewish \u201cprisoners of conscience.\u201d Because they make no specific political demands, the necklaces have become Rorschach tests for the right, left and center.&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>The pain and contradictions of a Jewish world in turmoil are reflected in the meanings they attach to the hostage discourse: solidarity, grief, justifications for Israel\u2019s war on Hamas, anger at the Netanyahu government, solace for the families of the captives, and a simple human and Jewish need to keep the plight of the missing in the spotlight.<\/p>\n<p>UJA-Federation of New York, the main funder of the JCRC, sells $18 \u201cDog Tags for Hostages,\u201d explaining their function in apolitical terms. \u201cThese dog tags \u2014 the same ones distributed throughout Israel by the Hostages and Missing Families Forum \u2014 remind us (and others!) to keep the remaining hostages still being held in Gaza constantly in our thoughts until all return home to their families,\u201d according to its website.<\/p>\n<p>On its own website, the Hostages and Missing Families Forum \u2014 the largest of the groups representing the families of the captives \u2014 offers the dog tags with a similar description, calling them symbols of \u201cunwavering commitment to bringing hostages and missing people home.\u201d&nbsp;<\/p>\n<div id=\"attachment_81401\" style=\"width: 1034px\" class=\"wp-caption aligncenter\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-scaled.jpg\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-81401\" class=\"wp-image-81401 size-large lazyload\" data-src=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-1024x768.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"1024\" height=\"768\" data-srcset=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-1024x768.jpg 1024w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-300x225.jpg 300w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-768x576.jpg 768w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-1536x1152.jpg 1536w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-2048x1536.jpg 2048w\" data-sizes=\"(max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px\" src=\"data:image\/gif;base64,R0lGODlhAQABAAAAACH5BAEKAAEALAAAAAABAAEAAAICTAEAOw==\" style=\"--smush-placeholder-width: 1024px; --smush-placeholder-aspect-ratio: 1024\/768;\" \/><noscript><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" aria-describedby=\"caption-attachment-81401\" class=\"wp-image-81401 size-large\" src=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-1024x768.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"1024\" height=\"768\" srcset=\"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-1024x768.jpg 1024w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-300x225.jpg 300w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-768x576.jpg 768w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-1536x1152.jpg 1536w, https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/06-07-24-Hostage-rally-Israel-2048x1536.jpg 2048w\" sizes=\"(max-width: 1024px) 100vw, 1024px\" \/><\/noscript><\/a><\/p>\n<p id=\"caption-attachment-81401\" class=\"wp-caption-text\">Israeli protestors set up bonfires and blocked roads in Tel Aviv during a demonstration demanding a hostage swap deal, May 5, 2024. The banner reads, &#8220;Fighting will not free the hostages \u2014 only a ceasefire will save lives.&#8221; (Photo by Itai Ron\/Middle East Images\/Middle East Images via AFP)<\/p>\n<\/div>\n<p>But while their messaging regularly focuses on Hamas atrocities and its violations of international law, the forum and its members have also been pointed in their domestic politics. In December, 80 days after the Hamas attacks, Nisan Calderon, brother of hostage Ofer Calderon, spoke at a rally organized by the forum. \u201cI call on members of the cabinet and the government to work for the return of all hostages now,\u201d he said. In March, 150 days after the attack, he spoke at a Health Committee meeting at the Knesset, complaining that no one from the Israeli government had contacted him \u2014 a common complaint among hostage families.&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>Yifat Calderon, cousin of Ofer, is a principal in We Are All Hostages.&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>Historically, American Jews have been uncomfortable publicly criticizing the Israeli government from afar. At the same time, many are now facing their own insecurity in the wake of the war and rising anti-Israel and antisemitic activism.<\/p>\n<p>\u201cI wear [the dog tag] because I feel a connection to Israel. And I feel that since I\u2019m not there, it\u2019s kind of the least that I could do,\u201d said Shelly Talmud, a mother of three in East Brunswick, New Jersey. Two of her sons have served in the Israeli military as \u201clone soldiers,\u201d and her oldest, still living in Israel, is a reservist. \u201cI feel it is important to show people that we haven\u2019t forgotten about the hostages.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>But Talmud also wears the dog tag, alongside a Star of David, as an expression of identity and defiance. \u201cI\u2019m very aware when I am wearing it that I am out there as Jewish, and it\u2019s a little frightening. But it\u2019s important to other Jewish people to see that I\u2019m wearing it,\u201d she said. \u201cAnd if somebody would start up with me, I\u2019d say, \u2018This has nothing to do with what\u2019s going on in Gaza. That\u2019s a whole \u2018nother conversation. I\u2019m just talking about the hostages and that they need to be released. I\u2019m not getting into a political thing with you.\u2019\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Since Oct. 7, Jews in Israel and the United States have developed an array of symbolic, public and ritual responses to the tragedy in Israel. They include empty \u201cShabbat table\u201d displays representing the captives, empty chairs in synagogues and at the seder table, pieces of masking tape with the number of days since the hostages were taken and \u201ckidnapped\u201d posters featuring images of the hostages. \u201cHostages Square\u201d in Tel Aviv has become a pilgrimage site for Israelis as well as American Jews visiting the country.<\/p>\n<p>Coming soon after Oct. 7, said Rabbi Vanessa Ochs, emeritus professor of religious studies at the University of Virginia, these responses \u201cwere about solidarity with Israel, and they were saying, \u2018My heart aches.\u2019\u201d<\/p>\n<p>As the war ground on, and Israel faced more criticism both at home and abroad, symbols like the dog tags took on new meanings. \u201cThey had a quality of \u2018I am with Israel no matter what. I will not criticize Israel,\u2019\u201d said Ochs, who is a scholar of new rituals and Jewish material culture. \u201cAnd for people who are critical of Israel it became a symbol of abdicating your role and responsibility for thinking about the consequences of what Israel is doing right now militarily.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Ochs said she was given a dog tag by a neighbor, \u201cand I was delighted to have it because my heart was breaking. But I never wore it, because I wasn\u2019t sure what meanings it would have in the different contexts in which I found myself.\u201d&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>Amanda Berman, executive director of the \u201cunapologetically Zionist\u201d Zioness Movement, understands that to many Israeli activists, freeing the hostages means supporting a ceasefire. But by wearing a dog tag (next to a chai and other Jewish symbols), she\u2019s expressing a different view of what it means to be \u201cpolitical.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>\u201cAs an American Jew and as a human being of conscience, I want the war to end. But the question since the afternoon of Oct. 7 has been, what has to happen in order for the war to end? And for me, that pressure should have been on Hamas to release the hostages and to stop shooting rockets and missiles into Israeli population centers and to stop threatening the sovereignty of the Jewish state,\u201d she said. \u201cAnd the minute that happens, the war will be over.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Berman\u2019s may not be a pro-war message, but it focuses responsibility on Hamas instead of the Netanyahu government. And it was similar to a message conveyed by a delegation from Kibbutz Be\u2019eri, a southern Israeli community hard hit during the Hamas attacks, that marched in New York\u2019s Israel parade. Or Gat, whose sister Carmel is a hostage and whose mother Kinneret Gat was murdered that day, told JTA that the goal of their 10-day trip to the U.S. was to raise awareness of the hostages and to speak about Hamas, \u201ca terror organization that\u2019s controlling Gaza and is the one that most hurts the Palestinian people.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>That too is a political message, but aimed at the broad goal of shaping public opinion about the war and its aims \u2014 a message endorsed by the Israeli government. \u201cI\u2019m wearing a #BringThemHomeNow dog tag in every interview and press conference as a reminder, for myself and the world media, why we\u2019re fighting,\u201d Eylon Levy, at the time an official Israeli government spokesman, tweeted in December.<\/p>\n<p>The We Are All Hostages movement wants more from American Jews, and said in their letter that they are available to speak to Jewish groups to press their case. \u201cYour voices are crucial to saving our family members. Your voices can help end this war. Lives hang in the balance,\u201d they wrote. \u201cOur families hang in the balance. We need you with us.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Jill Jacobs of T\u2019ruah said her group had come to a similar conclusion earlier in the war. On May 8, it issued a statement urging the Netanyahu government \u201cto make a hostage and cease-fire deal and bring the hostages home.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>She is aware, however, that even as the pro-Israel right abhors such implicit criticism of Israel, the pro-Palestinian left resists empathy for the hostages \u2014 and that the \u201ckidnapped\u201d posters were often torn down or covered.&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>\u201cThere\u2019s this idea [on the left] that it\u2019s somehow a contradiction between calling for a ceasefire and saying anything about the hostages,\u201d she said. \u201cI wish that people on the far left in the U.S. understood that a ceasefire and bringing home the hostages are actually the same things. They\u2019re not different sides.\u201d&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>In Washington, D.C., since shortly after the Hamas attacks, about 100 people gather every Sunday for a \u201cBring Them Home Now\u201d rally in front of the American Red Cross headquarters. Because they are Israeli Americans \u2014 members of the group UnXeptable D.C., formed before the war to protest Netanyahu and his proposed judicial reforms, later pivoting to support Hamas\u2019 victims, aid Israel\u2019s vulnerable populations and advocate for the release of the hostages \u2014 the vigil organizers have tried to straddle the line between what the cause means back home and to non-Israeli American Jews.&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p>\u201cAt first we were very careful not to be political, and the strongest goal we had was to keep the issue of the hostages in the public eye,\u201d said Vered Guttman, a food writer, one of the rally organizers and a representative of the Hostages and Missing Families Forum in Israel. \u201cAfter about three months we were starting to be more frustrated with the Israeli government. And as more time passed, it became very clear that it\u2019s a political issue that we could not ignore \u2014 or ignore what was happening in Gaza.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>The speakers started to demand that the government sign a deal, and to praise President Joe Biden for talking about the hostages and an endgame to the war in ways that Netanyahu avoided. Most of those attending the vigil are American Jews, who keep returning while occasionally bristling at the politics of some of the speakers.<\/p>\n<p>\u201cWe\u2019re kind of gentle,\u201d said Guttman, noting that while UnXeptable speakers will call on the Israeli government to sign a ceasefire deal, they invite guest speakers from across the political spectrum, from Sen. Chris Van Hollen, the Maryland Democrat, a frequent critic of Israel, to Robert Satloff, executive director of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, which has close ties with Israeli officials.<\/p>\n<p>Such an approach, she said, \u201cmakes our tent wider, and it brings a new audience to the discourse.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><em>Andrew Silow-Carroll is the editor of the New York Jewish Week.<\/em><\/p>\n<div style=\"padding-bottom:20px; padding-top:10px;\" class=\"hupso-share-buttons\"><!-- Hupso Share Buttons - https:\/\/www.hupso.com\/share\/ --><a class=\"hupso_toolbar\" href=\"https:\/\/www.hupso.com\/share\/\"><img decoding=\"async\" data-src=\"https:\/\/static.hupso.com\/share\/buttons\/share-medium.png\" style=\"border:0px; padding-top: 5px; float:left;\" alt=\"Share Button\" src=\"data:image\/gif;base64,R0lGODlhAQABAAAAACH5BAEKAAEALAAAAAABAAEAAAICTAEAOw==\" class=\"lazyload\" \/><noscript><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/static.hupso.com\/share\/buttons\/share-medium.png\" style=\"border:0px; padding-top: 5px; float:left;\" alt=\"Share Button\"\/><\/noscript><\/a><script type=\"text\/javascript\">var hupso_services_t=new Array(\"Twitter\",\"Facebook\",\"Google Plus\",\"Pinterest\",\"Linkedin\",\"Tumblr\",\"Email\");var hupso_background_t=\"#EAF4FF\";var hupso_border_t=\"#66CCFF\";var hupso_toolbar_size_t=\"medium\";var hupso_image_folder_url = \"\";var hupso_url_t=\"\";var hupso_title_t=\"OP-ED%3A%20%E2%80%98Bring%20them%20home%E2%80%99%20means%20different%20things%20to%20Israelis%20and%20American%20Jews\";<\/script><script type=\"text\/javascript\" src=\"https:\/\/static.hupso.com\/share\/js\/share_toolbar.js\"><\/script><!-- Hupso Share Buttons --><\/div>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"","protected":false},"author":3,"featured_media":81400,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"ngg_post_thumbnail":0,"footnotes":""},"categories":[22],"tags":[208,9872,40,6630,8781,3357,3303],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/81399"}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/3"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=81399"}],"version-history":[{"count":1,"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/81399\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":81402,"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/81399\/revisions\/81402"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/81400"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=81399"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=81399"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.crescentcityjewishnews.com\/blog\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=81399"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}