Wednesday, November 18th 2026   |

Rabbis for sale

By TED ROBERTS, the SCRIBBLER ON THE ROOF

There’s good news if you’re looking for a rabbi for your shul – or even for your family. You never heard of a family rabbi? I’m told rich people indulge in this luxury. It’s a smart economic move if your family‘s big enough. It beats shul membership dues and he’ll never attack you – his employer – from the bimah for a Saturday golf game. Not if the salary is adequate.

I read in the Jewish press that there are more choices of rabbis these days than Baskin-Robbins flavors; there’s a surplus of rabbis. So many shuls are cutting back. So, when you interview your next candidate, you might add painting the shul or some light landscaping to his duties.

What an occupation! And so many varieties. Having led an unsettled life in pursuit of a buck and moved so frequently, I’ve interfaced with every category of rabbi you can imagine. Strong and weak, young and old, shouters who could lecture us Israelites from the peak of Mt. Sinai to those who colloquially converse from the pulpit.

My ideal is the knowledgeable type (all aren’t) who understands the tolerance of Judaism. “The tent of Judaism is a large one.” (No, that’s not a Talmudic quote – it’s mine.)  But he also sees the distinct beauty of Judaism. Our “kinship” so to speak – our unique relationship with the Creator of the Universe. And vice-versa. The code that stamps us as Jews. I like a rabbi who emphasizes our chosen status and the obligations that go with it. We are not like the Joneses. My favorite rabbi is gloriously, politically incorrect on this issue. He believes with passion that we are a chosen people, that we have a mission and that the light of Zion in the heavens’ lighthouse is ours to focus on a stormy, foggy world.

I like a rabbi who is a guide, not a scoutmaster or drill sergeant. This means that though he is a leader of the flock, he, too, is a sheep in the meadows of belief. And despite his greater knowledge of Judaism, is no closer to the eternal mystery than you or me. I like humility in my rabbi. (Somerset Maughm recommended that beside each judge, pardon my crudity, stand a roll of toilet paper on the bench – just to remind him that he, too, was human. I suggest the same for rabbis.)

Interestingly, I had a conversation on this score with one of my adult children. Sometimes, you know, occasionally, once in a while, rarely you can learn from children. (Safe to say, since odds are he’ll never read this admission – I hope.) He pointed out that the rabbi was more “mindful” – a well chosen word – of G-d than myself since he prayed three times a day at least and on numerous other occasions. Touché! I know when I’m licked. But that assumes that the Lord of all is pleased by or desirous of prayer. For a nanosecond let us be questioning: Do we know that’s true or would He be closer to a subject (Are we not all his subjects?) who tithed regularly or dashed in front of a speeding cement truck to rescue a toddler?  Who knows? My ideal rabbi would answer, “I’m not yet in heaven.  Life is but a dream to me as it is to you.  And for all the instruction in our Holy Books, I only know for sure one unarguable rule. He loves goodness – He hates evil. Dogmatism should not be in the rabbi’s repertoire.  He should be as impassioned, as observant so that he wouldn’t play football (“pigskin” you know) but he must have a dash of Maimonides’ rationalism.  It’s all about reason – the G-d-given tool that He gave us to deal with his world.  A distinctive human blessing not given to dogs and cats.

And he must be a teacher who doesn’t swear at his students. Fire and brimstone are not in our lexicon. Hell is not a Jewish concept. So, he should instruct without shouting or threats. Most do, I’m happy to say.

And he need not be a pillar of the wider ecumenical community. I want his energy focused on my Temple or Synagogue. We pay his salary – we want his services. He doesn’t have to ride in the float on Chamber of Commerce Day. He need not win any popularity contests.

And of course he should visit our aged and our sick to remind them that G-d heals both mind and body.

To put it succinctly, the rabbi that inspires us should be devoted to his or her shul, knowledgeable and equipped with a heart that understands that there are many pathways to the ultimate Giver of Life and the pursuit of happiness. He also should have a dollup of personal charm that decorates his sermon and relationship with his congregation. But let me clarify. He should not be a performer, a verbal acrobat. You’ll pardon the expression – he should not be a ham. And he need not play a musical instrument.

Our Tanach – our total Bible – tells us what we should and shouldn’t do, but much of the Chumash assumes the Temple is still standing tall – so there is much about Temple behavior and our responsibilities, but less about rabbinic Judaism and man-to-man behavior and what we might call Hometown Judaism. My ideal rabbi should understand that and fill in the blanks. G-d is a mystery that is built on faith. Maybe He is less concerned about our behavior to Him than to our fellow man. My ideal rabbi should at least consider this possibility

Share Button