Rabbi David Nesenoff appears tonight at Metairie Chabad event
Over two years ago Rabbi David Nesenoff in tow with his teenage son Adam accepted an invitation to Jewish Heritage Day at the White House. At the time he had no idea they were about to alter history or have a hint this trip might lead to his embarking on a new career. A Conservative rabbi for the past 27 years Nesenoff, 52, has enjoyed a number of side careers. He has been a filmmaker, a musician and lately has added the titles of journalist, author and publisher to his curriculum vitae.
Rabbi David Nesenoff appears at Metairie's Chabad Center on Tuesday night. (Photo courtesy David Nesenoff)
But on that bright spring day on the grounds of the White House, the Nesenoffs had left the majority of their video camera equipment inside poised for a later conference. Accompanied by another budding broadcast journalist Jewish student friend of his son, Nesenoff whipped out his small, palm-sized flip video camera as he spied an elderly woman whose elbow was locked around a female colleague supporting her. “I knew she was a famous journalist,” he admitted, “but I knew nothing of her politics.”
He remembered seeing her in several movies, appearing as herself. At that moment he might not have known she was, in fact, a pioneer in journalism, one of the first women political reporters in Washington and a feminist role model. She was a hard-nosed journalist who stood toe to toe with her male peers and rose to become the public face of United Press International (UPI) in Washington. Beginning in the Kennedy administration, she was afforded the honor of asking U.S. presidents the first question at press conferences. Decades later, in 1982 UPI changed its focus as a news service and downgraded its staff. It was then that she became a Hearst syndicated columnist. Her name was Helen Thomas.
Nesenoff figured she was a fitting subject for a couple of quick questions and he fixed his video on her craggy face. The first was somewhat innocuous: As a veteran journalist, what advice did she have for these young people starting out in press corps? He pointed to the teenagers. “Go for it. You’ll never be unhappy. You’ll always keep people informed and you’ll always be learning,” the 89-year-old answered in earnest. “The greatest thing of the profession is: ‘Never stop learning.'”
Had Nesenoff thanked her for her time and moved on to his next subject, his life might have taken a different course. But he didn’t. “Ultimately, the creator of the world, who writes the stories, had something different in mind for me,” he opined.
Earlier, in his mind, he had decided he would try to garner some comments from attendees about Israel. It was, after all, Jewish Heritage Day and wouldn’t this be an appropriate venue to gather little snippets about the Jewish state?
“Any comments about Israel?” Nesenoff asked. Had Thomas known how her poorly chosen words would come back to haunt her, she might not have answered the inquiry. But with little regard as to how her answer would be received by a man, his son and another teenager all wearing traditional kippahs (skullcaps), she smiled into the camera with a defiant reply. “Tell them to get the hell out of Palestine,” she remarked.
“Ooooh!” Nesenoff answered, hurt and stunned by her words. He tried to give her a way out to redeem herself. “Any better comments about Israel?” he shot back.
She laughed out loud, encouraged by her friend, who continued to maintain her armlock about her. No sooner had she stopped laughing a few seconds later, she continued her tirade. “Remember these people are occupied and it’s their land,” she said. “It’s not German (sic). It’s not Poland.”
As a man who lost relatives in the Holocaust, Nesenoff was flabbergasted. “She went out of the way to be rude and offensive to me,” he recalled. At the very least, he thought, she was being disrespectful to the two teenage boys with her vitriol, but he also couldn’t fathom how anyone could bring up the two European countries that had experienced the greatest loss of Jewish culture during the Holocaust.
“This person could not hold back her animosity and disdain for the Jewish people and Israel,” Nesenoff proffered. “That was the first shocker.” But unbridled, she piled on more.
“So where should they go? What should they do?” Nesenoff asked.
“They could go home,” Thomas responded simply.
“Where’s home?” quipped Nesenoff.
“Poland. Germany,” she answered.
Nesenoff couldn’t believe his ears. “So, you’re saying the Jews should go back to Poland and Germany?’
Thomas started to nod in approval. “And America…and everywhere else,” she added. “Why should you push people out who have lived there for centuries?”
So, he followed up with a question that made sense to him. “Now, are you familiar with the history of that region and what took place there?” He was not prepared for her answer.
“Very much so. I’m of Arab background,” she shot back with a curious combination of pride and defiance.
The interview concluded with the rabbi attempting to converse with Thomas in Arabic, but she protested that she could only speak a few words. “We were too busy Americanizing our parents,” she claimed. As she left, she turned to the two young journalists and encouraged them to “Go for journalism. You’ll never regret it.”
For his first interview of the day Nesenoff had struck gold and he knew it. Just who was this woman journalist and how could she be so rude? “She was beyond offensive,” he commented.
Nesenoff had already maintained his own website, RabbiLIVE.com, but because his son was preparing for finals that next week, he had to bide his time before posting the raw video a week later with Adam’s help. The rabbi suspected he had a video that could go viral. He called upon the Jewish media to alert them to what could potentially be a major story. Nesenoff was surprised by their response.
“I told the Jewish Week right away and they said it was a ‘no’ story,” he said. “They had no interest.” Eventually, though, public pressure forced their hand. Also reluctant to publish the piece, according to Nesenoff, was JTA, the news service of the Jewish people. Once the story broke and was shared on other sites, it was carried over the major networks. It was only then, according to the rabbi, they did run the story, but not before they also ran a provocative video of Nesenoff shot at a Purimspiel (Purim skit). In that video Nesenoff was seen in a costume portraying a Mexican that some considered a racist attack or at the very least in very bad taste. The rabbi claims that it was an attempt at character assassination on JTA’s part. (JTA is in the process of moving offices and has not yet had an opportunity to comment on his charge.)
Once the video went viral and received more than a million hits, Nesenoff received what he claims were dozens of death threats and even more hate mail. Several of the more inflammatory and vulgar of these postings he has since placed on his website.
Within a few days Thomas issued a statement claiming she deeply regretted saying the words attributed to her in the video. But it was not enough. Within a week of the posting on RabbiLIVE.com, there was so much pressure for Thomas to resign that she abruptly announced her retirement from the Hearst Corporation on June 7, 2010. Coincidentally, the firestorm concerning her comments began during the week of the Gaza flotilla raid by Israeli forces.
At that time Nesenoff also ran afoul of political commentator Keith Olbermann, who thought his video was an unfair “ambush interview.” He labeled the rabbi “the second worst person in America.” Another critic has been Joy Behar, who felt Nesenoff was tearing down an American feminist institution. Also, according to Nesenoff, criticism came from several sources at MSNBC cable TV.
Another organization that thought Nesenoff was operating as a rogue journalist was the Society of Professional Journalists (SPJ), also known as Sigma Delta Chi fraternity. After Thomas’ resignation, it was pointed out to them that one of their most coveted journalism awards had been named in her honor. In view of her distasteful remarks and her public disgrace, the organization considered its choices, but refused to bow to public pressure.
Nesenoff notes that SPJ did alter that position, but it was six months later when Thomas had one additional rant against the Jewish people at her alma mater, Wayne State University. Thomas was quoted as saying that Congress, the White House, Hollywood and Wall Street are all “owned” by Zionist Jews. “Then they took it away from her,” he said. Wayne State also removed Thomas’ name from their “Spirit of Diversity” award.
Like it or not, Nesenoff’s entry into the world of advocate journalism, particularly as a friend of Israel and the promotion of the Jewish people, can be defined as having started with his impromptu interview of Thomas. It has created new opportunities for him.
He and his son took off on a crossroad adventure, traveling 3,000 miles and interviewing Jewish celebrities like Jackie Mason, known anti-Semites like Tom Metzger of the White Aryan Resistance, Congressman John Lewis and people in the street for a self-financed film about hate, Judaism and politics. Titled “3,000 Miles,” it premiered last fall at the Simon Wiesenthal Center in Los Angeles.
Nesenoff also conducted several interviews in delicatessens, which have ended up on You Tube. He has posted these under the title of “Pastrami and Politics.”
These days Nesneoff has become even more politically charged. Previously, a confessed liberal by design, he advocated for and supported the candidacy of President Barack Obama four years ago. Yet, he has become increasingly disillusioned with what he perceives as Obama’s embrace of Islam and his distance from Israel.
He spent six months living in Israel and his son and daughter have recently returned from extended trips there as well. Following the affair that catapulted him into the public eye, he became a publisher of not one, but two different Jewish newspapers. He was named the editor and publisher of the Jewish Star in New York and has also started an English and Hebrew newspaper based in Israel’s capital, the Jerusalem Observer.
“We’re facing a nuclear Iran. My children have been living in Israel. I love Israel and I love the United States and we’re facing a nuclear Hitler,” he warned. “The media has to be there. Someone has to report on what is going on.”
Despite the recent inclusion of language that regards Jersualem as the capital of Israel in the Democratic platform, Nesenoff said he believes President Obama is playing politics as usual in his re-election bid. “I don’t need him watching Israel’s back,” he continued. “I feel like I was a liberal who got mugged at the White House. I think his relationship with (Binyomin) Netanyahu and how he treated the prime minister in a totally disrespectful way was my tipping point.”
Over the past two years the rabbi has become more associated with the Chabad Lubavitch movement both religiously and politically. Following his sojourn to Israel, he moved to Boca Raton and now worships at the Chabad center there.
Currently on tour for a book titled “David’s Harp,” a series of poems and commentaries culled from his columns for the Jewish Star, Nesenoff will be appearing in the area this week.
Tonight, on the anniversary of the 9/11 attacks on America, he will be the featured speaker at the Gerson Katz Chabad Center in Metairie at 7:00 p.m. He will be speaking about his commitment to Israel and the present dangers he perceives from Iran and new Egyptian President Mohammed Morsi. He will be reading from “David’s Harp” and copies of the book will be available for sale that night. The event is $15 at the door.
