Friday, November 20th 2026   |

‘Kosher Queer’ panel draws full house at GOP

Rabbis Robert Loewy and Uri Topolosky drew such a large crowd with the second of their continuing education “kosher” series last Wednesday night that more rows of chairs needed to be added to the back of the room. The “Kosher Queer” discussion, held in the Bart Room of Congregation Gates of Prayer dealt with Reform and Orthodox differences in how to be inclusive or how to accept Jewish members of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Questioning (LBGTQ) community.

Rabbis Robert Loewy, left, and Uri Topolosky at the "Kosher Queer" discussion last Wednesday. (Photo by Steve Binkowitz)

Loewy gave a historical analysis from the Reform community’s perspective, noting that the move from awareness towards unilateral acceptance in the governing body of the Reform movement – formerly called the Union of American Hebrew Congregations (UAHC) and now called the Union for Reform Judaism (URJ) – started approximately 35 years ago. According to Loewy, UAHC clergy at first began to follow what he termed a “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy until the calls for non-discrimination led to important reforms and eventual acceptance. Some of these changes included services being created for same sex marriages and civil unions. But not all rabbis in the Central Conference of American Rabbis (CCAR), the Reform rabbinical association, welcomed these changes. Loewy admitted even he had to wrestle with some unanticipated demons of his own in coming to terms with full acceptance of LGBTQ rights within Reform Jewry.

Even though the Recontructionist movement, founded by former Conservative Rabbi Mordechai Kaplan, has fully accepted LGBTQ members in their synagogues, the Conservative movement is still divided over the issue.

Topolosky observed that he personally knows of no one in his Orthodox synagogue who is gay. He conceded that Orthodoxy “struggles” with accessibility within the LGBTQ community. Some passages in the Orthodox liturgy are problematic because they specifically forbid homosexual practices, he said.

Ayla members talk to the audience at Gates of Prayer as Rabbis Uri Topolosky, second from right, and Robert Loewy facilitate. (Photo by Steve Binkowitz)

Topolosky pointed to a recent controversy in a New Jersey community over the placement of an announcement for a same sex marriage, which created a furor among several Orthodox rabbis. When the New Jersey Standard publicly apologized to the rabbis, Topolosky related, it created an even greater firestorm from another rabbi who pointed out that the newspaper’s policy accepted ads promoting non-kosher foods at restaurants. That rabbi expressed dismay as to why an apology should be issued for a wedding announcement.

Topolosky said that Orthodox rabbis often encourage members of the LGBTQ community to get married to straight partners and “deal with it.” However, he said, this flies in the face of other Orthodox values, which state that any individual should not be made to do something he or she does not wish to do.

Two members of Ayla, a community organization founded in 2010 to support Jewish members of the LGBTQ community were on hand to respond to questions from the audience. Ayla was founded by Jordan Aiken, a former member of AVODAH: The Jewish Service Corps,  who worked in New Orleans advocating for social justice for LGBTQ members. Even though Aiken has returned to her home in California to be close to family, Janine Jankovitz and Leah Krandel said their organization is very strong in its support of members of the Jewish LGBTQ community.

They explained that Ayla is the Hebrew word for “oak tree.” The logo of the organization is a spreading live oak with the Hebrew word spelled out in its leaves and the English equivalent listed across the base of the tree on it bark.

Jankovitz talked briefly of her journey to discover her sexuality and admitted that she has only recently come out to the world about it. Despite the fact she is not a lesbian, Krandel contended her work as an LGBTQ advocate with Ayla has led to her receiving hate mail. Both Ayla members asked questions of Loewy and Topolosky and inquired if a recent Ayla training session they had attended a month earlier had given them better insight into how to reach out to the LGBTQ community.

Rabbi Uri Topolosky (Photo by Steve Binkowtiz)

Some suggestions from Ayla members included listing more pictures of gay couples in synagogue and temple bulletins and encouraging the use of  “gender neutral” bathrooms in which everyone would be allowed equal access.

Both rabbis encouraged feedback from audience members to indicate how they could better communicate with and reach out to LGBTQ members. Topolosky ended the night with a reference to a lecture he had written titled “Moses Had Two Mommies.” In it he pointed out that the biggest influences in his life were the women in his two families. “A family structure isn’t always mom, dad, brother or sister,” he noted. “All families look different.”

The final discussion in the “kosher” series will be this Wednesday night at Congregation Beth Israel, 4004 West Esplanade Avenue. Topolosky will invite participants to discuss “Kosher Sex” beginning at 7:30 p.m.

Share Button