Rabbi Topolosky has final word on ‘Kosher Sex’
Taking the lead from the title of Rabbi Shmuley Boteach’s book, Rabbi Uri Topolosky finished the continuing education “kosher” series between Reform Congregation Gates of Prayer and his own Orthodox Congregation Beth Israel this past Wednesday night with the racy theme of “Kosher Sex.”
The talk by Topolosky held at Beth Israel was largely based on quotations and readings derived from the Torah and the Talmud. It followed the previous two “kosher” discussions held at Gates of Prayer – “Kosher Jesus” and “Kosher Queer” – the previous two Wednesday evenings had been led by Rabbi Robert Loewy.
Topolosky dispelled what he called the most famous myth about Jews and sex. That, he said, was the ridiculous notion that observant Jews had sex through a hole in a sheet. The origin of the myth was created when non-Jews observed four-cornered undergarments with tzitzits being hung out to dry when washed. The large white garments had the appearance of sheets and the “holes” were in fact there to allow one’s head to pass through when being donned. Having never seen them nor knowing what they were, the rabbi said, non-Jews assumed the white “sheets” were used in private for sexual practice.
“In Jewish law sexuality and intimacy is supposed to happen without any barriers,” he pronounced and related to the audience that rabbis had been discussing the topic for thousands of years. In light of the previous discussion on “Kosher Jesus,” Topolosky said that “Judaism has a fundamentally different take on sex as opposed to Christianity.” The three foundations of the Jewish practice of sex can be expressed in three simple statements: Sexual life is normal. It should be fun and pleasurable. It’s private.
Relating back to the Book of Genesis (Bereshit), Topolosky touched on the statement”Be fruitful and multiply.” “This is important,” he said. “This is a divine mandate.”
He stated that the act of love is intended to bring G-d into the bedroom. In the Bible the word “knew” is used to express the act of lovemaking. “Love is meant to be a process of knowing each other, of clarifying, knowing what each other is about,” he continued.
Topolosky touched on the laws of family purity and how a woman’s menstrual cycle is considered by Judaism as something that should not go unnoticed. “We need to stop and acknowledge the potential for life has not been actualized,” he explained. “That means it’s almost akin to a brush with death has occurred.” During the seven days following a cycle women are forbidden to engage in sexual activity. Then, seven days after their cycle has ceased, they go to the mikvah to renew themselves in those healing waters and come out on the other side to begin the process again, he said.
During the period before they enter the mikvah, the husband can learn the value of intimacy without physicality. “Hone your skills as a love partner,” he advised, “You should be able to get in touch with your partner’s needs without phiysical touch.”
He said that the cyclical nature of the use of the mikvah can be like a “mini-honeymoon” each month as the couple renew their intimacy. “It can be a very powerful thing.”
The rabbi reiterated that “There is absolutely no act, there is nothing forbidden between a loving couple.” Every imaginable sexual act between loving couples is permissible under Jewish law, he stated. “I think it’s very important for young people to know (this).”
Before closing out for the night, he touched on a question regarding contraception, which , he said, is permissible under Jewish law, although the use of condoms is not widely sanctioned because of the Biblical admonition against a man “spilling his seed.”
Another questioner followed up on the previous week’s topic of “Kosher Queer” and asked the rabbi how Orthodox Judaism regards sex between same sex couples. He expressed his belief that the Biblical prohibition against a man lying with another man as a woman was fairly explicit.

