In closing, the Declaration of Independence invokes “the Supreme Judge of the World” – reprising Abraham’s plea before God: “Will the Judge of all the World not do justice?!” (Genesis 18:25). Liturgical images of God as Judge include the High Holy Day prayer, l’El Orech Din: “God Who Dispenses Justice.”
Upon receiving unwelcome tidings or, specifically, news of a death, we recite the blessing Baruch Dayan Emet: “Praised be God, the True Judge.” A poignant lesson for mourners: no matter how well we knew a loved one or friend or neighbor, we have only a part of the picture, a fraction of the truth. God alone knows the whole story, the full account of a person’s life, accurately weighing all its goodness and failings, foibles and kindnesses.
Rabbi Yishmael (Rabbi Akiba’s frequent partner in debate), taught: “Do not judge alone, for none may judge alone except for One” – that is, the One God (Avot 4:10). Justice is ill-served by single-minded, doctrinaire ideologues. There is much to be gained when judges moderate their own views by consulting with others of sometimes differing perspectives. Even God consulted with Abraham before rendering his verdict on a corrupt society. Perhaps it was precisely the Supreme Judge’s receptive and consultative spirit the Founding Fathers had in mind.
(Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the National Chaplain of the National Jewish Committee on Scouting.)