Merry
By RABBI JOSEPH H. PROUSER
Too often, Jews react to the Christmas season and its customary greetings with unnecessary discomfort.
The Talmudic sage, Rabbi Yeba, understood the Mishnah to teach that Jews properly greet non-Jews on their religious holidays (Gittin 62A). Maimonides codified Yeba’s insight: such holiday greetings are to be offered “in the interests of peace” (Hil. Avodah Zarah 10:5). The sixteenth century Rabbi Moshe Isserles ruled that if we come into a community and find non-Jews celebrating a religious holiday, “we should make merry with them!” (Y.D. 148:12).
During the Christmas season, we ought to greet the Christians among whom we live in unprecedented peace and amity (and gratefully accept their greetings) because we value their friendship.
During the Christmas season, we ought to greet our Christian neighbors and gratefully accept their greetings on principle, because we sincerely value their religious expression over the deceptive, destructive allure of secularism and nihilism, with which the religious enterprise (including our own) competes for attention.
During the Christmas season, we ought to greet our Christian neighbors and gratefully accept their greetings because such a pattern of courteous social interaction was prescribed by the giants of rabbinic leadership from the very founding of our tradition.
Shammai understood: “Say little, do much, and greet ALL people with a cheerful countenance.”
(Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the National Chaplain of the National Jewish Committee on Scouting.)
