Wednesday, November 18th 2026   |

OP-ED: The patriotic path

By ALAN SMASON

In the opening of the movie “Patton,” George C. Scott gives an impassioned speech as he channels General George S. Patton’s love of battle and the ultimate thirst for victory. 

The opening scene in “Pattton.” (©1970 20th Century Fox)

“I want you to remember no bastard ever won a war by dying for his country,” he famously states. “He won it by making the other poor, dumb bastard die for his country.”

We have seen steady progress in the war against COVID with some 51 million people inoculated nationally against the virus through the Pfizer, Moderna and Johnson & Johnson vaccines. In Louisiana nearly one third of the state has successfully completed its regimen of two shots or a single dose in the case of Johnson & Johnson’s vaccine.

But with this success comes news of a disturbing trend.

According to the most recent Louisiana Survey released yesterday, April 1, by LSU’s Reilly Center for Media and Public Affairs, one third of the state’s population and almost half of its Republicans say they will not be inoculated. This disparity cuts across political lines and is especially troubling for a variety of reasons, but paramount among them is that this a real question of life and death.

It’s not just a personal decision to save one’s own life. It is an act which advances our striken society towards herd immunity, a condition which will eventually prevent the spread of the virus, expert epidemiolgists say.  By conflating vaccination refusal with that of, say, not wearing a mask in public, this sector of the state – one third of the population, but 49% of Republicans – is confused and choosing personal rights over that of the public good. 

Without achieving vaccination rates of at least 70 – 80%, it is entirely possible the pandemic could continue unabated. Fiscal Republicans should be among the first to stand in line to alleviate the damage already done to the economy by the lockdowns. By refusing to be vaccinated they are prolonging the suffering of the multitudes and hampering businesses from recovery under already uncertain times.  

Back in the 1950s, when the Salk polio vaccine came out and, later in the 1960s, when the Sabine sugar cubes were administered to the public, no one argued about their right to be paralyzed and crippled. Everyone feared this disease, which struck randomly and cut down productive young adults and innocent children, killing or scarring them for life. 

COVID-19 is indiscriminate. It knows no religious beliefs or political convictions. It kills Republicans. It kills Democrats.  Just as disturbing is that nearly one-tenth of Democrats who responded in the poll also indicated they were reluctant to get vaccinated. Statistically, if more Republicans refuse vaccinations, more Republicans will die. It’s hard to fathom that is their real intent.

So, if fear of death isn’t enough to encourage anti-vaxxers to rethink their position for themselves, perhaps they will think of the others in our state still at risk depending on them to do the right thing.  

Politics and medicine mix as easily as oil and water. It’s not too late to remove the political agenda and the shaming or stigma attached to becoming vaccinated. If people are truly interested in our state’s recovery and in our nation returning back to what we once regarded as normal, we have to consider this as a patriotic decision in defense of our nation, no less important than enlisting to fight an enemy during wartime.

Perhaps we should also recall another quote in that famous “Patton” opening scene.  If a grandchild were to ask what he did during the Great Second World War, Patton admonished soldiers to avoid the remark “I shoveled sh*t in Louisiana.”

When asked by our progeny what we did during the COVID pandemic, the majority of Democrats appear to be letting the other poor, dumb Republicans die for their country. 

And those that aren’t busy dying appear to be busy shoveling. 

Share Button