Coveted
By RABBI JOSEPH H. PROUSER
At age 14, I underwent an Eagle Scout “Board of Review” – the final required hurdle to achieving the highest rank in Scouting. I vividly recall questions about my Scouting experience, survival skills, family relationships, moral values, devotion to God, and my personal definition of “reverence.” As the lengthy and (it seemed) grueling interview drew to a close, the presiding officer asked a series of scripted questions. He said repeatedly:
“If you are granted the covered [sic] rank of Eagle Scout….”
Even at age 14, I realized he was mis-reading the script. He meant “the coveted rank….”
Even at age 14 I realized it would be impolite (and not in my own immediate self-interest!!) to risk embarrassing the seasoned youth leader by correcting his English!
Even at age 14, I understood the irony in being questioned about “reverence” by someone who did not recognize the word “covet” – the core of last of the Ten Commandments!
Philo explains “Thou shalt not covet” as suppressing desire, “the fountain of all iniquity, from which flow all improper actions, whether important or trivial” (XXXIII:1.173-174). I suppressed my desire to point out the gentleman’s error!
Rabbi Yakum taught that to violate “Thou shalt not covet” is tantamount to violating all Ten Commandments simultaneously (Pesikta Rabbati 21)!
That just about covers it!
(Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the former National Chaplain of the National Jewish Committee on Scouting.)
