OP-ED: Time for change at the Coroner’s Office
By ALAN SMASON
The job of the Coroner of the Parish of Orleans is to serve the needs of the public, oftentimes during a period of mourning when family and friends are experiencing overwhelming loss, grief and despair. Orleans Parish Coroner Dr. Dwight D. McKenna acknowledges the office’s important function through his office’s mission statement on their website: “Our mission is to provide timely, thorough, accurate, and independent medico-legal investigations,” it reads.
Sounds simple enough.
But the tragic and sad facts are that his office appears to be performing at a less than satisfactory level.
News reports from a joint investigation by WWL-TV and The Times-Picayune/ New Orleans Advocate paint a picture of a critically impaired operation at the Coroner’s Office.
Two different victims – Benjamin Pfantz and Justin Smith – were both unable to be identified in a timely fashion to their next of kin and what’s worse is their bodies were allowed to decompose due to a lack of available refrigeration equipment (what the office calls “coolers”). The families of both victims searched for an unacceptable period of time, hoping their loved ones were still alive, only to find out months (in the case of the Pfantz family) or weeks later (in the case of the Smith family) that the Coroner’s office had failed to identify the victims being housed in their own facility by examining their fingerprints in a timely fashion.
In the case of Mr. Pfantz, the badly decomposed body was cremated before the parents could be alerted that their son’s body was being held at the Coroner’s Office. A misspelled name (“Paentz”) was apparently the root cause for the failure to identify Mr. Pfantz and his family has now filed a suit against both Dr. McKenna as the coroner and also against his office’s insurance company.
In the case of Mr. Smith, the body was also in an advanced state of decomposition due to a lack of proper refrigeration efforts. Critical evidence of possible foul play was likely lost due to improper storage of Smith’s body, his family alleges.
The Coroner’s Office claims it has contacted the Mayor’s Office for help in initiating repairs to the coolers. At a budget review in the New Orleans City Council chambers, president J. P. Morrell specifically questioned Coroner’s Office representatives several weeks ago regarding the failing refrigeration equipment. Information from the joint investigations but not corroborated by the CCJN suggests the coolers have been out of order for several months and that no contingency plan exists for future repairs. The Pfantz family alleges in their suit that no written policies exist regarding the timely identification of bodies by the Coroner’s Office.
Instead of launching an internal investigation, the Coroner’s Office issued a statement following the news reports, demanding an apology and a retraction from both the newspaper and the TV station, alleging they “misrepresented the facts of this case.” Smith’s body was picked up in front of the Jax Brewery as a result of a drug overdose on June 18, according to the New Orleans Police Department, and received at the Coroner’s Office a day later. Dr. McKenna’s statement says that fingerprints were taken “within days” of Smith’s death on June 25 – actually six days later – by Homicide Detective David Trahan. (Detective Trahan has failed to return calls to the CCJN.)
According to WWL-TV’s David Hammer and the newspaper’s Ben Myers, the N.O.P.D. has claimed no one from the Coroner’s Office ever contacted them. The Coroner’s Office offered their own explanation that an “NOPD fingerprinting machine was out of order and we were forced to wait for it be repaired.” No one at N.O.P.D. headquarters understands to what the Coroner’s Office is referring, according to the Smith family. No machine is needed to read fingerprints, they say, at least not one that would be out of order for weeks on end. According to the Smith family, a failed air conditioning system at N.O.P.D headquarters did necessitate the relocation of several staff members who would ordinarily be assigned to fingerprint identification.
That the Coroner’s Office is literally feeling the heat is without question. But the time is not right for pushback and demands for apologies. The time calls instead for a spotlight to be focused on their practices and for plans to be put into action to prevent another tragic recurrence.
Holding one body on premises, failing to identify the next of kin and allowing the body to decay is horrific. Losing two bodies in this manner borders on gross incompetence. There’s no time now for recriminations and pushback. We need substantial change and an attitude of compassion coming from the Coroner’s Office. Dr. McKenna need not be reminded that he serves at the pleasure of the public. There must be swift change within his office or change will come roaring back in the wrath of disillusioned voters at the polls.
(For the record, Justin Smith was a second cousin to CCJN editor Alan Smason)
