Wednesday, November 18th 2026   |

OP-ED: Turning a phrase into a censure

By ALAN SMASON

The United States Speaker of the House Mike Johnson made the announcement late last night with no fanfare. After escaping several measures intended to punish U.S. Representative Rashida Tlaib (D-MI.) for seeming to justify the murderous October 7 Hamas attacks, her Congressional colleagues had finally censured her for crossing the line by promoting the phrase “From the river to the sea” over her social media.

The full phrase is “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.”

Rashida Tlaib in 2018. (Photo by Stephanie Kenner/Shutterstock)

While the phrase has been associated with calls for Palestinian independence since the 1960s, it has been the rallying cry for  the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) as well as a founding principle of Hamas since its formation in 1988.  That was the very year the PLO announced its intention to focus on the creation of a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders of Israel and to abandon its aims to destroy the Jewish State. Out of those meetings and discussions, the Palestinian Authority (PA) was born and administered by the ruling Fatah Party.

Hamas, which was born originally as a charity group through its fellow terrorist organization, the Muslim Brotherhood, has violated the peace process between the leaders of Fatah and the Israeli authorities at every step since its founding. Through a series of suicide attacks and by fanning the flames of hate in the region when peace was looming, Hamas has never abandoned its stated goal to eradicate Israel and to kill every Jew. Islamic Jihad and Hezbollah, also proxies of Iran, have also followed suit.

The Jordan River and Mediterranean Sea established the border eastern and western borders of the British Mandate that controlled the area before the independence of Israel.  A call for borders to exist from the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea would suggest the destruction of a national homeland for Jews and the creation of an Arab state in its place.

As the only elected Palestinian-American in Congress, Tlaib has been a firebrand for her people through the years and has been sharply critical of Israel’s policies along with a number of key Democrats. But none of them had ever deigned to utter a phrase that many view at its base as anti-Zionist and at its worst as antisemitic. 

In the past Tlaib was able to dial back her comments and withstand any challenge to her position. However, her embracing of the Palestinian phrase, abbreviated or not, is a bridge too far in Congress. While the Israel-Hamas war rages, she needs to understand that as an elected official, she must be held to a higher standard, especially when her words can be interpreted by rank and file Americans as encouragement to act out against Jews or to exacerbate an already tense situation.

 

 

 

 

Share Button