OP-ED: Hamas says “oops”
By ALAN SMASON
After a remarkable weekend in which dozens of Israelis, Americans and foreigners were released from captivity through the intercession of numerous diplomats and statesmen, there seemed to be hope that the humanitarian pause demanded by so many here in New Orleans and elsewhere around the world would blossom into a full blown cease fire.
Israeli security at the scene of a terror shooting attack at the entrance to Jerusalem, Nov 30, 2023. (Chaim Goldberg/Flash90)
Tensions have been high among the Qatari, Egyptian and Americans attempting to broker a delicate deal between Hamas and Israel, whose enmity is so great they require intermediaries to carry out conversations.
There were small infractions that threatened the process once it began. Deadlines for providing lists of hostages who would potentially be released were ignored by Hamas. Israel kept threatening to ramp up the military onslaught that has brought so much bloodshed in northern Gaza. Yet, somehow the tenuous peace process was kept alive oftentimes by a slender thread, even if it seemed a conflagration could erupt at any moment.
Then, this morning a car in Jerusalem carrying two men brandishing automatic weapons opened its doors and the men began shooting at human targets waiting at a nearby bus stop. Israeli security forces responded quickly by returning fire. In the end, three Israelis were killed and six were wounded. The gunmen also lay dead in the street.
Incredulously, instead of distancing itself from the brazen attack, Hamas proudly accepted responsibility for the terrorist action.
They claimed the attack was intended to answer for the killing of two young boys in the West Bank town of Jenin by Israelis forces yesterday as well as to underscore their resistance to the Israeli incursion into Gaza. That military action followed the horrific Oct. 7 attack in which 3,000 armed terrorists invaded Israel’s sovereign territory, resulting in the deaths of 1200 Israelis and others – including 11 Americans – and injuries to thousands more.
The attack this morning has grave repercussions. It’s not like they can say “Oops!”
Of course, nothing can justify the continued use of violence and killing by Hamas. The only reason it appears they have considered allowing the Palestinian people to receive humanitarian assistance and be out of harm’s way is that they underestimated the Israeli response to their organization. The relentless pounding of their infrastructure including the network of underground tunnels from which they operate and where they are apparently holding the hostages was a public relations nightmare for Israel but at the same time a series of stunning military victories.
But it came at a high cost. The unacceptably large number of Palestinian casualties can be attributed to Hamas embedding itself in populated areas and using ordinary Gazans as human shields or collateral targets. Hamas has also threatened displaced Palestinians from moving to safer areas, despite Israeli pleas to do so.
Even though Israel has announced there will continue to be widespread death and destruction as long as hostages are being held, this morning’s terrible act of terrorism did not disrupt the peace process. Much to its credit, Israel continues to count its mounting death toll at the hands of Hamas and somehow continues to try to be reasonable as it faces an unreasonable situation.
If Hamas continues down the path of violence and death sanctioning more of these kinds of terrorist acts, though, it has no one to blame for the Israeli response than themselves.
At this perilous time, Hamas should know terrorist acts like today’s attack are counterproductive and threaten the humanitarian pause of which they had clamored a week ago. Israel has thus far released three Palestinians for every single captive released by Hamas. If Hamas expects to continue receiving similar consideration by Israel in the future, it must stop sanctioning the killing of more Israeli citizens.
Israel is already at a breaking point and there is little doubt that its leaders and citizens are becoming numb to the deafening outrcy on social media that excoriates the IDF for soi-disant war crimes and falsely paints its citizens as genocidal colonizers.
Restraint on both sides needs to be exercised if any further progress can be achieved. Hamas has poked the bear. What happens next can mean the difference between families being reunited and families bemoaning further loss. The stakes are too high to let one or two bad actors determine the outcome.
