Wednesday, November 18th 2026   |

ICJ ruling explained, reactions listed

The International Court of Justice, the United Natiions highest court,  issued a ruling today on South Africa’s case against Israel.

The Peace Palace at The Hague, home to the International Court of Justice.(Photo by Velvet via Wikimedia Commons)

Regarding the crime of “genocide,” the nine-member panel ruled that South Africa, had jurisdiction because, like Israel, it had signed the Genocide Convention, even though it was not a party in the dispute. The court did not issue a ruling on whether or not Israel was guilty of the crime of genocide, but it did state that Israel did not have to enforce what could have been a mandated ceasefire.

Reaction to the ruling was swift and condemned by many pro-Israel groups.

Sarah Stern, founder and President of the Endowment for Middle East Truth (EMET) said: “South Africa’s claim is nothing more than a blood libel erroneously hurled at the only Jewish state for defending itself after the October 7th Massacre. South Africa, like many other anti-Israel nations, does not really care about the Palestinians or human rights for that matter, it only cares about delegitimizing Israel. Pretoria’s own human rights record is abysmal, with widespread arbitrary killings, torture and government corruption.  The preliminary ruling of the Court indicates that this is nothing more than political theater. If Israel cannot protect and defend itself from radical Jihadist groups, how will, in fact, the rest of Western civilization?”

Combat Antisemitism Movement (CAM) CEO Sacha Roytman Dratwa was also highly critical.

“The ICJ’s interim ruling, coming a day before International Holocaust Remembrance Day, shames the memory of those who fought against genocide and the six million Jews on whose ashes the Genocide Convention was built,” he stated. “The ruling strips the rights of their descendants, the Jewish people in their indigenous and ancestral homeland, of their right to prevent another genocide. It sets a precedent which will deny the right of defense from all democracies fighting against terrorists who embed themselves among civilian populations. The ruling will be learned and studied by all terrorist organizations around the world and serve as a blueprint for them to be able to achieve their own genocidal aims, without censure or attack. “

Dratwa did agree with one part of the ruling. “Finally,” he concluded,” we recall that the ICJ made an unequivocal demand to immediately release all of the hostages, something which we share.”

Share Button