Tzedakah (“charity”) – an affirmative obligation of Jewish Law – is also regulated by a prohibition in the Torah: “Do not harden your heart or withdraw your hand” from the needy (Deuteronomy 15:7). Under most circumstances, we are forbidden to refuse the direct request of a poor person for modest monetary assistance.As a young rabbinical student in a New York neighborhood replete with homeless people reliant on charity for subsistence, I always made sure to have cash or pocket change with me, so I could properly respond to such requests.
Naturally, I carried no money on Shabbat. One Shabbos, a homeless individual approached me for some “help.” I sheepishly began to explain that it was the Sabbath… that I therefore had no cash… that I would find him the next day to compensate for my unavoidable refusal. The indigent man gently gestured for me to stop apologizing, smiled broadly, and gratefully announced: “Oh! I understand! Saturday is my baddest day!”
I was inspired to realize that my needy neighbor associated philanthropic generosity with Jews of religious principle… a connection that would have been less manifest without our additional commitment to Shabbat. Saturday was his “worst of times” financially… but my indigent fellow New Yorker perceptively attributed his “best of times” to the demands of Jewish piety.
Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the editor of “Masorti: The New Journal of Conservative Judaism.”