Wednesday, November 18th 2026   |

Base Metals (and Instincts)

By RABBI JOSEPH H. PROUSER

It is customary among Torah scribes that no base metal (steel, iron, copper) be used in the production of Torah scrolls.  This precludes writing with a metal pen or stylus, as well as use of most metal blades when the scribe must scrape errant ink from the scroll.  (Aruch Ha-Shulchan YD 271; “Sofer: The Story of a Torah Scroll,” by Eric Ray and Joel Grishaver).

During a recent Shabbat morning Torah reading, I discovered two glaring scribal errors in the congregation’s Torah scroll.  As I am trained as a Mesader Gittin – a scribe for divorce documents – I had both scribal ink and quills on hand to make the minor repairs (after the Sabbath!).  The required emendations necessitated removal of small segments of the mistaken letters.  To effect these corrections, I used a decades old, sterling silver carving knife from my late mother’s kitchen… thus maintaining the tradition of  avoiding base (as opposed to precious) metals. The Sefer Torah was returned to legitimate liturgical use the following Shabbat.

William Ellery Channing, a leading nineteenth century Unitarian theologian, provides insight into the meaning of this scribal regulation:

“Conscience, the sense of right, the power of perceiving moral distinctions, the power of discerning between justice and injustice, excellence and baseness, is the highest faculty given us by God.”

Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the editor of “Masorti: The New Journal of Conservative Judaism.”

Share Button