Hillel and Shammai disagreed regarding the proper method for kindling Chanukah lights (Shabbat 21B). Hillel (establishing our own practice) taught that a single candle is lit on the first night, and that the number of candles is increased by one each night of the Holiday, culminating in eight lights on the final night. Hillel’s reasoning: “In matters of sanctity, we always increase rather that decrease.”
Shammai, conversely, prescribed that eight candles be lit on the first night of Chanukah – and that that number be decreased each night, with but a single flame on the eighth night! Shammai modeled his approach on the number of bulls sacrificed on the Festival of Succot: thirteen on the first day, with that number decreasing by one each subsequent day… culminating in seven bulls sacrificed on the final day (See Numbers 29:12-31). The total number of sacrificial bulls, seventy, corresponds to the proverbial seventy nations of the world… thereby invoking God’s expansive favor upon them.
Shammai saw in Chanukah’s message of national self-determination, religious freedom, and resistance to despotic persecution a luminous blessing the Jewish People is duty-bound to share with the world… anticipating the insight of Justice Louis Brandeis: “As a part of the eternal, world-wide struggle for democracy, the struggle of the Maccabees is of eternal world-wide interest.”
(Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the former National Chaplain of the National Jewish Committee on Scouting)