Tuesday, November 17th 2026   |

Dissent

By RABBI JOSEPH H. PROUSER

Esteem for dissenters and minority opinions has featured prominently in Jewish tradition from the earliest moments of our history. The first Patriarch of Israel was Avraham Ha-Ivri – Abraham, the Hebrew (Genesis 14:13).

While “Hebrew” (Ivri) may simply denote a descendant of Eber, it is widely understood to identify Abraham as “one who crossed over” (avar) the river Euphrates. More than a geographic indicator, this etymology asserts moral independence.

Abraham, in embracing monotheism and its corollary moral demands, stood apart. He championed unpopular views and a decidedly minority opinion in a world of paganism and moral chaos. He stood alone: across the river, as it were, from prevailing values and conventional wisdom. Abraham – Avraham Ha-Ivri – founded the tradition of dissent. (See Genesis Rabbah 42:13.)

Abraham’s legacy of dissent lives on in Rabbinic law and literature. Virtually every page of the Talmud reverently preserves minority opinions for posterity. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, much celebrated for her own incisive minority opinions, effectively evinces this Talmudic ethos when she explains that “Dissents speak to a future age.”

To be a worthy heir, a moral disciple of Avraham Ha-Ivri, is to be willing to dissent, to stand apart… to take a principled but unpopular stand when the situation or the times demand.

Of course… you may disagree.

(Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the National Chaplain of the National Jewish Committee on Scouting.)

Share Button