Holidays (feasts and fasts) lend substance and character to the Jewish year… embodying some of the most important values of Jewish Tradition. What would the Jewish approach to repentance and self-improvement be without Yom Kippur? What would Jewish devotion to freedom be without Passover?
In the long history of Judaism, some holidays have fallen into desuetude and been forgotten. The Shulchan Aruch (O.H. 580:1-2) prescribes a wise but much neglected fast day (to be marked this coming week) during the otherwise joyous month of Adar: “On these days misfortune befell our ancestors, and it is proper to fast thereon… on the ninth of Adar, for the rift between the Schools of Shammai and Hillel.”
The Rabbis deemed it appropriate to express national contrition for this infamous spiritual rift within the Jewish community… though that dispute never approached the rancor, harshness, violence, and contempt which attend Jewish religious politics today (or, similarly, American “civil” discourse).
On this Ninth of Av let us remember that “the contradictory teachings of Hillel and Shammai are all words of the living God” (Eruvin 13B). Or as U.S. Senate Chaplain Peter Marshall prayed in 1947: “Let us be tolerant of the thoughts of others, for we never know in what voice Thou wilt speak.”
May we reclaim this timely wisdom. Fast!
(Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the former National Chaplain of the National Jewish Committee on Scouting.)