Gabriel Greenberg offered contract as new Beth Israel rabbi
The good news for Congregation Beth Israel is the Modern Orthodox synagogue does have a new rabbi, posed to take over the position being vacated by Rabbi Uri Topolosky at the end of this month. The bad news is that Rabbi Gabriel Greenberg, who accepted the position in principle, must honor his commitment to the Hillel at the University of California at Berkeley for nearly another year and won’t be full time in New Orleans until May of 2014.
A vote by acclamation of the Beth Israel general membership on June 19 assured Greenberg of the Modern Orthodox synagogue’s intent to have him take over duties as its spiritual leader.
That vote followed months of an active search by a nine-member committee charged with writing a job description, reviewing resumes and conducting interviews from a field of 27 candidates. Using traditional phone interviews and modern computer technology like Skype, the committee further reduced the field to a list of three candidates, two of whom, like Topolosky, were ordained at Yeshivat Chovevei Torah Rabbinical School (YCT). The dean of the yeshiva, Rabbi Avi Weiss, additionally recommended a third candidate from his school, that being Greenberg. The problem was that Greenberg felt his recent selection as the Hillel rabbi at the Berkeley campus required he honor a commitment to be there for at least a year.
According to search committee chair and synagogue gabbi Irwin Lachoff, the first three candidates came in for on site interviews and spent time with the congregation over the course of several weeks. “But the committee decided that, before they made a formal recommendation, they had a responsibility to the congregation to interview Rabbi Greenberg, as the Committee thought he exhibited too much potential and that at the very least we should conduct a formal interview,” wrote to his fellow congregation members in the official committee report.
“We conducted that interview and we all agreed he should be brought in to meet the members of the congregation,” explained Lachoff. The rabbi impressed the committee members.”There was overwhelming feedback from the members of the congregation that he was the right fit for us,” acknowledged Lachoff.
Following the general membership vote, a contract was extended to Greenberg by executive board members.
Lachoff indicated the transition will be somewhat daunting. For example, according to sources, other community rabbis may be called upon to assist with graveside services for departed members in the interim. Beth Israel’s Cemetery rules dictate that an Orthodox rabbi must conduct the service, but it is thought that synagogue administrator Rabbi David Posternock, an ordained Orthodox rabbi, could work in tandem with the other community rabbis while Greenberg is still in California.
“We understand that the next few months may pose challenges and inconveniences, but we feel that having the right fit is worth the wait,” Lachoff wrote in his report to the congregation. “We look forward to Rabbi Greenberg’s upcoming visits and the transition process.”
Greenberg’s first meeting with congregation members will take place on the weekend of July 19-21, his official welcome to Beth Israel. He is expected to take part in Mincha and Kabbalat Shabbat services, starting at 7:00 p.m. on Friday, July 19. A community dinner at 8:00 p.m. will follow. The cost of the dinner will be $18.00 per person.
Once Topolosky exits, Greenberg is expected to make regular, perhaps monthly, appearances at the synagogue. However, he will not be joined by his wife and infant son until after the end of the Succot holiday for Shemini Atzeretz, according to Posternock.
It is also possible that student rabbis from YCT may be asked to assist with worhship services on a once-per-month basis, said one source. It is also probable Beth Israel will have lay-led services during the transition period.
(Editor’s note: The CCJN gratefully acknowledges the cooperation of members of Congregation Beth Israel in compiling this story.)

