Wednesday, November 18th 2026   |

OP-ED: Giving Thanks Where It’s Due

At the Fed Fest last Wednesday evening in the Audubon Tea Room, hundreds of New Orleans Jewish community members gathered to honor community leaders and to congratulate themselves over another successful year.

As they dug into their salads, the background of clinking glasses and whispered conversations was punctuated by shouts, sirens and noisemakers coming from a boisterous outside crowd of 30 demonstrators carrying banners and Palestinian flags. Kept at abeyance by New Orleans Police officers while occupying public access space outside, the protestors kept up a constant barrage of noise throughout the night. Meanwhile, Federation supporters inside went on with their program.

At one point, Sara Lewis, the recipient of the Herbert and Margot Garon Young Leadership Award, acknowledged the elephant in the room. “Honestly, I’d like to also thank the protestors that we’ve been listening to this entire evening,” she reflected as the crowd gave out a stilted collective laugh. She went on to explain that it is through the efforts of Federation and the progress they have made in working with the greater outside community that the Jewish community is made safer.

While the protestors outside rambled on with their slogans and antisemitic tirades through their bullhorns, the New Orleans Jewish community cheered the fact they had enjoyed a record-breaking year of fundraising in the year since the October 7 coordinated Hamas attacks on Israel and the resulting Gaza War. This past year they raised an unprecedented $5 million for the annual campaign that funds Federation programs and its constituent agencies.

The fact is the Hamas attacks and their strategy of seizing hostages has backfired on them. Instead of achieving strategic victory and demoralizing the Israelis, the potent response from the Israel Defense Forces has resulted in the dismantling of Hamas’ network of terror tunnels, the deaths of their top leaders and wreaked havoc in the areas they formerly controlled.

Hezbollah, which began its pounding of northern Israel on October 8, 2023 the day following the Hamas attacks, has also felt the response from Israel in Lebanon.  Using technology to target pagers being held by operatives to explode on signal, Israel succeeded in killing many of its rank and file. Hezbollah’s stockpiles of weapons has largely been destroyed and, following the collapse of Bashar al-Assad’s tyrannical government in Syria, the IDF now controls strategic Mount Hermon.

Yet, despite the continued evacuation of its towns in the northern region bordering with Gaza and the deaths of 815 members of the IDF, Israel has largely become stronger and proven its military superiority. Although the Biden administration at times pushed back against Prime Minister Netanyahu’s response, they never wavered in giving military support and provided for Israel’s defense, even when Iran launched two attacks of drones, rockets and missiles at the Jewish State. Now, with the election of Donald Trump, Israel’s posture with the U.S. government shows the prospect of warming even more.

With the exception of their holding Israeli and American citizens as hostages, Hamas has been decimated and demoralized. Knowing now what they did and the disastrous outcome, Hamas might well have chosen a different option. 

Although Sara Lewis’ sentiment is heartfelt, we can never extend thanks to Hamas for their gross stupidity.

Their barbaric and inhuman attack on Israel led to the deaths of more than 1,200 Israelis, 46 Americans and 30 other nationalities and the capture of 250 hostages. But, their heinous actions also brought about a galvanized Israeli response and solidarity within our own local Jewish community.

Indeed, Jews in New Orleans are laser focused. Having to put up with the dinnertime rants and chants of lunatics on bullhorns advocating for Hamas may be unsettling, but the need to raise more money than ever to help support our local community’s needs, to partner with the community-at-large and to align more closely with Israel has never been more important.

In the end, we should give thanks to ourselves for doing the right thing and staying the course during these troubling times.

 

Share Button