OP-ED: Should the Western Wall Be Part of ‘Palestine?’
By RAFAEL MEDOFF
If US Senator Chris Van Hollen has his way, the Western Wall will be taken away from Israel and made “part of Palestine.”
In a May 30 op-ed in the New York Times, Van Hollen (D-Maryland) wrote that the US should declare that it considers “Gaza and the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, as part of Palestine.”
Advocates of redividing Jerusalem use the slippery term “East Jerusalem” because it sounds as if it’s already some kind of separate Arab city that naturally should be part of a Palestinian Arab state. But no such city exists, nor has it ever existed.
Sen. Van Hollen was referring to the neighborhoods of Jerusalem that Israel won, in self-defense, in the 1967 war.
Some of those neighborhoods are in the northern part of the city (French Hill, Neve Yaakov, Ramat Shlomo); some are in the southern part (Gilo, Har Homa); and the best-known is the walled section in the eastern part, known as the Old City. Historically, that was the original core of Jerusalem, before all the additional neighborhoods were built around it.
The Old City neighborhood is where the holiest site in Judaism, the Temple Mount, is located. Also the Western Wall, dozens of historic synagogues, and Jewish residential areas dating to biblical times. Adjacent to the Old City is the Mount of Olives, the site of the oldest Jewish cemetery in the world, which includes the final resting places of biblical prophets and Talmudic sages.
Last September, former US official Philip Gordon wrote an op-ed in the New York Times in which he referred to “the Palestinian-populated cities of East Jerusalem, Ramallah and Bethlehem.”
Ramallah and Bethlehem are indeed separate cities, and they are exclusively “Palestinian-populated” (because the Palestinian Authority, which governs them, forbids Jews from living there). But there is no such city as “East Jerusalem.”
I submitted a letter to the editor, pointing out that error. My letter also noted that it was erroneous for Gordon to refer to “East Jerusalem” as “Palestinian-populated,” when the eastern part of Jerusalem has a substantial Jewish population.
The Times declined to publish my letter, but an editor sent me a note informing me that they had deleted the word “cities” from the online version of Gordon’s op-ed. That corrected the first error, but not the second.
Earlier this week, I submitted another letter to the Times, in response to Sen. Van Hollen’s op-ed. I explained that when he wrote that “East Jerusalem” should become part of “Palestine,” he was actually saying that the Temple Mount, the Western Wall and the Mount of Olives should be torn away from the Jewish people and handed over to the control of the Palestinian Arabs.
The last time those sites were under Arab rule, during the Jordanian occupation of 1948-1967, Jews were barred from praying there, the Western Wall was turned into a garbage dump, and thousands of Jewish tombstones from the Mount of Olives were used to pave nearby roads and latrines in Jordanian army barracks.
The Times hasn’t published my recent letter, either.

