Wednesday, November 18th 2026   |

OP-ED: The end of the war or just wishful thinking?

With its leadership in disarray and little prospect of any of its goals of eliminating Israel still viable, Hamas gave into threats by the incoming Donald Trump administration of “hell to pay” and agreed to a hostage deal that neither they or the present Israeli government led by Benjamin Netanyahu truly wanted. 

While the ideals of fighting to the last man may be a romantic notion for swashbuckler movies and novels, the realities of modern warfare and the devastating destruction laid upon Gaza by the Israel Defense Air Force and ground troops of the IDF made continuing the conflict foolhardy.

Indeed, the entire deadly misadventure that began on Oct. 7, 2023 with a coordinated sneak attack by land, sea and air on Israel – timed to play out during the early morning hours of the Simchat Torah holiday – turned out to be a great victory.

Only the Israelis were the victors.

With Netanyahu and (until recently) Defense Minister Yoav Gallant’s aggressive response against Hamas, the opportunity to root out the most dedicated and determined Hamas terrorists proved to be too tempting for Israel. With coordinated air attacks and targeted assassinations in both Gaza and Tehran against key Hamas leaders, Israel proved they were capable and willing to kill anyone who threatened them. Israel largely destroyed the system of terror tunnels Hamas had installed since 2005 and exposed how the terrorists used schools, hospitals and residences to launch rocket attacks.

Following Hamas’ lead, Hezbollah, another Iranian proxy, elected to enter the fray on Oct. 8, when it began its series of relentless missile and rocket attacks on Israel, eventually facing a directed attack into its borders by Israeli ground troops and with drones taking out a huge number of their hardened launch sites.

But the biggest trick up the Israeli sleeves played out on September 19 and 20, 2024, when Israeli officials triggered explosive charges contained in pagers and walkie-talkies that Hezbollah figures had unknowingly used for communications for years. Israel’s Mossad agents had secretly planted the explosives in devices sold through third parties. Neither the Koreans who sold the devices nor Hezbollah officials who purchased them had any indication that the devices had actually been manufactured in Israel. As a result of the explosions, dozens of Hezbollah terrorists were killed or maimed when the devices detonated.

Hezbollah capitulated in late November, ultimately agreeing to a ceasefire that has laregely held.

Another byproduct of the drawn-out Israel-Hamas war was the toppling of the Syrian government of Bahsar al-Assad. While Israel did not assist the rebels who routed Assad and sent him fleeing to exile in Russia, it did enter Syria during the end stages of the civil war as a “humanitarian” gesture to lend assistance to those in need there. Like Assad, it is doubtful that the rebels will ever recognize Israel, but Assad’s deadly campaign against Druze and Christians – some allegedly conducted with banned chemical weapons – has been eliminated.

For the jingoistic right-wing Israelis, many of whom are associated with the so-called settler movement, this ceasefire comes too early. More needed to be done, they would argue.

For the more liberal of Israelis, who in the spirit of Yizhak Rabin have sought reconciliation with the Palestinians, the ceasefire comes too late. The long road to mutual trust again may be insurmountable. It was the Palestinians who embraced Hamas and elected them to office.

For the families of the abducted and the dead, the time for healing must begin now. It is hardly time to celebrate any victory, real or imagined.

For the 840 dead Israeli soldiers who gave up their lives to defend Israel, their families will continue to grieve. Were we to compare the number of dead on a percentage basis, 840 Israeli dead would translate to approximately 40,000 U.S. troops killed. It is a significant number and, coupled with the more than 1200 killed on Oct. 7 and the thousands of injuries incurred on that date, this war represents the deadliest and most devastating statistics since the founding of the modern State of Israel in 1948.

The ceasefire and initial release of hostages, including the release of the remains of an Israeli soldier killed a decade ago, is only the beginning of a series of three phases. We can only hope the lessons of the past 15 and a half months will continue to impress all parties involved. 

Now is the time to receive the hostages and to begin rebuilding both lives and structures. We need to give out hugs to our missing loved ones, to put down the guns, to begin to take up hammers and to get relief to those that need it.

We also need to remember that no victory ever was sustained by maintaining a posture of war. If were are ever to imagine the possibility of long-lasting peace, there must be a philosophy that promotes peace and cooperation between peoples and – perhaps eventually – nations on both sides.

If not, as Shakespeare suggested, all of this is “a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.”

 

 

Share Button