OP-ED: When hate wins, we all lose
By ALAN SMASON
The last several weeks have been all about Ye, the artist formerly known as Kanye West, and his diatribe about going “def con 3 on Jewish people.” Ye, who has gone off on diatribes before had not specifically pronounced such blatant antisemitic vitriol before.
When pressed for additional comment, his response on a podcast was to alert the media that he was untouchable. “I can literally say antisemitic s— and they cannot drop me,” he bragged.
One brand, Balenciaga, took out an ad in Women’s Wear Daily to announce it had severed any existing ties it had with the rapper. Ye countered he was a victim of the “Jewish underground media mafia.” While many might have wondered what Ye was smoking on that particular day, it should be pointed out that Balenciaga’s decision followed a controversial Paris Fashion Week show in which Ye and Balenciaga revealed a new “White Lives Matters” brand of fashion wear.
Perhaps Balenciaga officials had lost their perspective for a while. The pushback in Paris and around the globe was more against the sentiment espoused in fashion wearers expressing a stance on White supremacy than there was a specific conspiracy against Ye.
But then the other shoe dropped.
Adidas, the German shoe manufacturer with past ties to Nazi founders, had been largely quiet. After all, the athletic shoe manufacturer’s Yeezy brand brought in about $250 million worldwide, approximately 10 per cent of its annual $2 billion gross. It’s one thing for a company to take a stand when it costs them nothing and another when it might mean a significant loss of revenue.
But, to its credit, Adidas did see the light. Prompted by an initial tweet from one of its own Jewish executives and later pressed to break its relationship with Ye by the Anti-Defamation League and the Campaign Against Antisemitism, the company announced first that its relationship with Ye was “under review” in early October and then formally broke ranks with him last week.
Several media outlets have reported they also had removed Ye’s antisemitic rhetoric. Producers for HBO’s “The Shop” (with host and NBA star LeBron James) announced they were pulling an interview with Ye due to antisemitic speech contained within it. While Conservative firebrand Tucker Carlson did air a segment over his Fox News show last week, it was announced it had been selectively edited in order to remove hate speech directed at Jews.
Several White hate groups have seized the opportunity to brandish banners claiming “Kanye was right” and a similar banner was seen during Saturday’s broadcast of the college football game between the University of Florida and the University of Georgia.
Possibly hoping to ride Ye’s notoriety, NBA star Kyrie Irving added his own brand of antisemitism this last week as well. He promoted an antisemitic movie in which a false conspiracy theory of Jewish complicity in the Black slave trade is alleged. This disproven and discredited theory had been propounded by disparate Jew haters like Lewis Farrakhan and David Duke.
Strange bedfellows indeed.
Poor Ye. Perhaps last year’s highly publicized comments against Pete Davidson bear further scrutiny. Davidson was, after all, involved with Ye’s ex, Kim Kardashian, and, yes, Davidson is famously Jewish.
It’s so easy when one loses at life to lash out at Jews and to blame them for all the world’s ills. If those pesky Jewish people were to be removed, all of life’s tribulations – Ye’s crumbling fashion empire and his relationship with ex-wife Kim among them – would certainly be improved.
And based on nothing, how can anyone disagree? As Ye’s much maligned target Taylor Swift famously sang “The haters gonna hate.”
The faces of antisemitism may change, but its continual message of loathing beckons for all that will believe in its false prophesy. The most important thing is to recognize it for what it is and to call it out. It is hate. Pure and simple.
When antisemitism is allowed to go unchecked, we all are diminished. Adidas, Balenciaga, HBO and even Fox News know it’s bad for business.
Now it’s our business to put Ye in our rear view and acknowledge that when hate wins, we all lose.
