Organizing not one, but two Jewish worship services with the Order of the Arrow
By ALAN SMASON, Exclusive to the CCJN
My journalism training has always instructed me that a good reporter (or editor) should always write objectively and from a perspective that allows a reader to determine their own opinion about a subject. The caveat has been one should never become the object of a story – that a subjective or first person piece is almost always desired less.
Jewish Arrowmen act as hagbah and gelilah to wrap the sefer Torah at Orthodox worship services at NOAC on July 28, 2022. (Photo by Alan Smason)
But I have learned over the course of my career that some of the most enduring articles I have written have been first person articles that describe my ordeals with hurricanes or other climactic events. Sometimes an article requires the vantage point of a first person perspective.
Over the course of the last week, I have found myself ensconced in a college dormitory room in Knoxville, Tennessee as a delegate from the Southeast Louisiana Council of the Boy Scouts of America’s honor society, the Order of the Arrow (OA). The bi-annual gathering of this youth-run organization called the National Order of the Arrow Conference (NOAC) had been planned originally for 2020, but due to the COVID pandemic was pushed back two years.
Nearly 7,000 Scouting youth – boys and girls – and adult leaders have gathered to take courses and to engage in competitions related to the order’s ritual work. While women leaders have been admitted to the honor society for decades, girls have only become an integral part of the Order of the Arrow since 2019. But their effect on the previously male-only group has been dramatic. In many cases, the young ladies have assumed positions of leadership in their respective lodges and have become quite skilled in the competitions between lodges related to memorization of the ritual work maintained by this 107-year-old organization.
One aspect of the OA’s enduring commitment to reverence is expressed in the many ways religion is incorporated into its daily structure. Catholic and Protestant worship services are held each morning, but out of the thousands of delegates, only 100 identified themselves as Jewish. Among them was no rabbi or religious leaders. A Jewish worship service had not been held at NOAC for at least seven years and no one was sure who would be the appropriate person to lead Jewish worship at NOAC.
A Jewish Arrowmen, center, has an aliyah as Jeffrey Cohen reads from the Torah with assistance from Avi Udi, extreme right. (Photo by Alan Smason)
Several months ago, one of the OA’s Engagement Team members, a former Southern Region Section Chief from New Orleans, contacted me as a well-known Jewish Scouter figure and made inquiries as to whether a Jewish rabbi could be found to lead daily worship services at NOAC. My swift response was it was highly unlikely. Most rabbis are busy enjoying the remaining days of summer prior to the onset of the very busy period of the High Holidays, I explained.
Well, if a rabbi was not available, would I be able to organize services on a daily basis? Again, my response was pragmatic. It would be a monumental task that would require a great deal of effort, but I would look into it.
A longtime member of the National Jewish Committee on Scouting (NJCOS), I have taken specific Jewish committee training at Philmont Scout Ranch in New Mexico and received advanced training at a religious-observant Wood Badge course 20 summers ago. Since 2013, I have organized and maintained the NJCOS website as the IT vice chair.
But OA leaders had not dealt with me specifically prior to this NOAC as a facilitator for Jewish worship. Over the course of several phone calls and Zoom meetings, I explained Jewish worship services would best be executed on a Monday or Thursday morning when a Torah service might be held for the Orthodox community. But a minyan, the smallest amount of ten men that would allow public worship services and prayers like the Borchu and Kaddish to be recited, would be a stretch without getting a list of Jewish Arrowmen, as attendees are called.
Concerns over privacy of names and personal data were allayed as I promised not to share the list of Jewish Arrowmen. I organized a mail list and a specific email address to reach out to Jewish Arrowmen of all branches of Judaism, starting with a target audience of Orthodox men. After receiving RSVPs from more than ten men, the second aspect was dealing with the significant contingent of Jewish females who wanted to be included in their own worship services.
Several Jewish Arrowmen who posed for a photo after worship services on July 28, 2022. (Photo by Fr. Steve Arisman)
I reached out to the list via emails and was able to get permission from the Rabbinical Assembly of the United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism to post a special copy of their Sim Shalom Siddur on the NJCOS website.
In the end we had almost 30 adults, evenly split between Orthodox and Conservative (egalitarian) worship services held on Thursday morning, July 28 at 6:45 and 7:00 a.m., respectively.
A kosher meal of bagels, lox and cream cheese with orange juice was organized through the local Chabad of Knoxville under the supervision of Rabbi Yossi Wilhelm. The rabbi sent a Torah scroll along with Avi Udi, an Israeli member of his organization, who helped organize the Orthodox Torah service. Jeffrey Cohen, an observant Orthodox Scouter lead the worship service and read the Torah portion for the week with the assistance of his son and Udi.
Mark Kaye and I, both members of the NJCOS, were happy to contribute the cost of the meal and both the men and women who remained at the end of the breakfast stopped to pose for a picture to record the significant event. Father Steve Arisman, a Catholic priest, took the photo with my camera.
In the end nearly 30 Jewish Arrowmen – men and women – were able to enjoy worship services together and, more importantly, to connect as Jews within the framework of the BSA’s honor society.
So, forgive me, if this story has become a bit more personal than most of my others. It just couldn’t be helped this time.
