“Shomer Peta’im Hashem” (“The Lord protects and keeps the simple.”) This verse (Psalm 116:6) is cited by the Sages to justify a number of behaviors that are otherwise considered to entail risk to life or limb. (See Shabbat 129B regarding bloodletting; Yevamot 12B for a discussion of contraception and high-risk pregnancy; Avodah Zarah 30B on late night snacking.)
In each case, the rabbis conclude that – notwithstanding seemingly reckless personal choices – those of simple faith can rely on God’s providence and loving, protective care to shield them from harm.
The mid-15th century Terumat Ha-Deshen (Rabbi Israel Isserlin) and the Chatam Sofer (1762-1839), however, rule that knowledgeable Jews – no “simpletons” they – may not rely upon this scriptural “assurance.” They are obligated to exercise principled self-restraint and personal responsibility in safeguarding life and health.
Indeed, one might well read Psalm 116:6 in a very different light. “Shomer Peta’im Hashem” –Those who are simple or feeble-minded or self-delusive enough to forgo responsible safety precautions and hygienic practices (particularly during a public health crisis) may well soon find themselves in the keeping of the Divine… alas, in the Hereafter.
Jewish Law and morality – Jewish medical ethics – demand sound healthcare protocols and vigilant self-care.
Wishing all my readers good health… and good sense.
(Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel and the former National Chaplain of the National Jewish Committee on Scouting.)