Tuesday, November 17th 2026   |

Scholars and Prophets

By RABBI JOSEPH H. PROUSER

Rabbi Ismar Schorsch, Chancellor Emeritus of the Jewish Theological Seminary, is author of “Better a Scholar than a Prophet” – a series of essays exploring the rigorous, scientific, critical study of Judaism. His historical survey demonstrates that “the understanding of our most venerated figures and sacred texts stood to benefit enormously from an academic method that stripped them from the fictions of mythological thinking.”

Chancellor Schorsch takes his book’s title directly from the statement of Amemar, a fifth century Sage: “Chacham Adif Mi-Navi” (Baba Batra 12a). The Sages agreed: classical prophecy ended with the destruction of the Temple. The sound academic inquiry and penetrating scholarship of the Rabbis succeeded the work of the prophets in uncovering truth, in discerning (and revealing) God’s will, and – at its best – in achieving spiritually meaningful communion with the Divine.

The hard-won insights and discoveries of the rigorously disciplined scholar today are, similarly, to be preferred to the sensationalist, often antinomian preaching of claimants to mystical or prophetic knowledge… “influencers” who espouse visions untethered from precedent in Jewish history, or foundation in Jewish tradition. The productive quietude of the Study Hall is superior to the bombast and (sometimes alluring) imaginings of even the most wildly popular “prophet” or the most thoughtful “thought-leader.”

“Chacham Adif Mi-Navi.” Better a scholar than a prophet.

Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the editor of “Masorti: The New Journal of Conservative Judaism.” The latest edition of Masorti was published online in December of 2024. A subscription is $18 per annum

 

Share Button