We are enjoined by the Torah to remember “the day you stood before the Lord your God at Horeb” (Deuteronomy 4:9-10ff). It was at Sinai (Horeb) that the People Israel had our most direct experience of God’s Presence. At Sinai the Divine will was revealed. At Sinai the Jewish People reaffirmed our covenantal bond with God and determined, for all time, to express our national essence through the medium of revealed religious law. At Sinai, the Jewish national enterprise was born.
Notwithstanding our biblical duty to remember Horeb, Mount Sinai’s location remains a matter of dispute. A dozen mountains – in and outside the Land of Israel – vie for the distinction! A recent expedition mustered geographical and archaeological evidence that Mount Karkom, near the Egyptian border, is the true Sinai.
My Talmudic namesake, Rabbi Joseph, was nicknamed “Sinai” – bespeaking his remarkably encyclopedic knowledge of sacred literature and rabbinic texts… including especially the obscure and non-canonical (Moed Katan 12A). That enviable nomenclature is a reminder that we access Sinai not in remote desert climes, but in the piety, scholarship and spiritual journeys of accomplished souls and sages.
In the continuing search for Sinai, we do well to remember the wisdom of Edmund Hillary, first to summit Mount Everest: “It is not the mountain we conquer but ourselves.”
Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the former National Chaplain of the National Jewish Committee on Scouting.