Even the most abbreviated Passover Seder generally includes recitation of “The Four Questions” – providing the youngest of Seder participants an opportunity to bask in the adulation of loving adults. “The Four Questions” go back to the Mishnah. After the second cup of wine is poured, the Mishnah instructs, “Kan ha-ben sho’el aviv – Here the son asks his father” (Pesachim 10:4). Jewish sons and daughters have been asking “The Four Questions” (mutatis mutandis) for millennia! Jewish mothers and fathers have been doing their best to answer, and to pass along a sense of Jewish identity and collective national memory throughout those many centuries.
Some 50 years ago, a Boy Scout camp director taught me and my young compatriots: “Always conduct yourself so that the boy you were would be proud of the man you are.” Wise and useful counsel!
While I now profoundly enjoy hearing “The Four Questions” from grandchildren, perhaps the Mishnah is addressing itself not to children, but to adults at the Seder. “Kan ha-ben sho’el aviv – Here, at the Seder, ask yourself: Would the child you were be proud of the Jewish man or woman you have become?”
Poet William Wordsworth wrote: “The child is father of the man.”
“Here” — this Pesach – we are answerable to the questions of our inner child.
Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the editor of “Masorti: The New Journal of Conservative Judaism.”