Rabbi Yaakov Yitzchak Ha-Levi Horowitz – “The Seer of Lublin” – was a leading Chassidic master, who attracted followers and disciples by the thousands. After singing, dancing, and celebrating on Simchat Torah 1814, he somehow fell from a window and was grievously injured. Anti-Chassidic detractors, gloating at his moribund condition, vowed to dance on the day of his death. The Seer languished for many months, dying on Tishah B’Av 1815. His critics were thus halachically – perhaps providentially – precluded from acting on their spiteful triumphalism… as dancing and music are forbidden on that dark day of fasting and mourning.
This year’s observance of Tishah B’Av follows a deeply painful period. We mourn those who fell last Simchat Torah, during Hamas’ October 7 attacks against Israel… among them, young people who came to sing and dance and celebrate at the Nova music festival, only to be murdered and taken hostage. We lament the hateful rhetoric of detractors and enemies of the Jewish State and People.
The Seer’s title was based on his reputed, supernatural ability to see distant events as they transpired. Without any claim to the Seer’s prophetic gift, this Tishah B’Av – as always, the Seer’s yahrzeit – may we envision a State of Israel that lives out the creed of its now popular motto:
“We will dance again.”
Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the editor of “Masorti: The New Journal of Conservative Judaism.”