The Torah (see Deuteronomy 14) states that land animals must both chew their cud and have split hooves to qualify as kosher. Fish must have both fins and scales. Scripture provides no such anatomical markers for fowl. Rather, the Torah lists examples of bird species which are permissible or forbidden for Israelite consumption. The turkey appears nowhere on the list! This provoked some heated rabbinic debate: Is turkey kosher or not?
Memorably, Rabbi Yom Tov Lippman Heller (16th Century Cracow) counted turkey among the forbidden, non-kosher species of fowl. There are descendants of Heller to this day (a cherished teacher of mine among them) who abide by his stricture, and refrain from eating turkey: majority opinion and rabbinic certification to the contrary notwithstanding!
Heller’s restrictive approach reflects the principle that only fowl for which there is a “masoret” – a received, established tradition of their kosher status – may be consumed. Turkey was unknown in Europe before the 16th Century: thus, no tradition of permissibility. The turkey’s size, appearance, and aggressive bearing were also deceptively similar to those of forbidden birds of prey.
The debate has, happily for us (if not for the turkey!) been resolved: turkey is kosher. In fact, Israelis eat more turkey per capita than any other nation. Except, perhaps, Americans…
…on Thanksgiving Day.
Rabbi Joseph H. Prouser is the rabbi of Temple Emanuel of North Jersey and the editor of “Masorti: The New Journal of Conservative Judaism.”