Two rabbis named to take over pulpits at Beth Israel, Shir Chadash
By ALAN SMASON, Special to the CCJN
Emails went out this week from the presidents of Congregation Beth Israel and Shir Chadash Conservative Congregation announcing the impending arrivals of two new local rabbis for congregations in the Metairie area.
Harold Pesses, the Beth Israel president, notified his congregational members in the first of the emails that Rabbi Phil Kaplan had signed the contract extended to him by the Executive Board that had been recommended by the Rabbinic Search Committee several weeks ago. (CCJN editor Alan Smason served on that search committee.) Kaplan is a native of Queens and grew up on Long Island in New York.
He received his semicha when he was ordained from Yeshivat Chvevei Torah (YCT) in Riverdale, New York in 2019. Kaplan follows a string of Beth Israel rabbis, who all were ordained from YCT beginning with Rabbi Uri Topolosky and followed by Rabbis Gabriel Greenberg and Joshua Pernick. Pernick left at the end of April to take over as the Jewish Federation rabbi for the Hartford, CT. community. YCT is a Modern Orthodox yeshiva administered by Rabbi Avi Weiss.
Prior to his ordination, Kaplan attended City University of New York – Queens College, where he received a bachelor’s degree in Jewish studies. Following his ordination, he served as a rabbinic intern at Beth David Synaoguge in West Hartford, CT and later at Congregation Sherith Israel in Nashville, Tn. and at Congregation Tiferet Israel in Austin. Kaplan is a graduate of the AIPAC Leffell Fellowship program and received a Certificate of Spiritual Leadership and Social Impact from New York University, a fellowship from the iCenter for Israel Education and a unit of Clinical Pastoral Education at St. Thomas West Hospital in Nashville, TN.
He married his wife Abra Kaplan in June 2019 and the two moved to Sydney, Australia, where Rabbi Phil served as Associate Rabbi and Hazzan of The Great Synagogue there.
The rabbi has been very involved in teaching and pastoral care as well as leading musical services there for the past three years. He helped coordinate events for children and adults in the Great Synagogue Choir.
The Kaplans welcomed a son, Roee, in 2020, and recently moved back to New York prior to Rabbi Kaplan accepting the contract.
A congregational meeting will be held on Sunday morning, May 29, at 10 a.m. to approve the contract. Kaplan begins his term of office on Wed., June 1.
Meanwhile, Shir Chadash president Peter Title informed his congregation that terms of the contract with Rabbi Scott Hoffman had been approved and that he was set to take over as the congregation’s spiritual leader on July 1.
A native of Silver Spring, MD, Hoffman previously served as a rabbi at Congregation Chevra Thilim for two years from 1991 to 1993. He earned his bachelor’s degree in the Biological Basis of Behavior at the University of Pennsylvania in 1985 and was ordained from the Jewish Theological Seminary (JTS) shortly before his arrival at Chevra Thilim. While at JTS, he received the Hackenburg Prize as outstanding student in the field of midrash. In recent years, he also received a Ph.D. in Talmud and Rabbinics from New York University.
Hoffman’s pulpit work since leaving New Orleans, most of the rabbi’s pulpit work has been accomplished at two Jewish congregations on Long Island: the Lake Success Jewish Center from 1995-2007 and Temple Israel of South Merrick from 2007 until 2018.
Hoffman is a past president of the Rabbinical Assembly of Nassau/Suffolk/Queens and has served on the boards of the RA Executive Council, the Hillel Institute for Conversion, the Long Island Board of Rabbis, the Great Neck Interfaith Clergy Association and the Black/Jewish Coalition for Justice.
Married since 1989 to opera singer Phyllis Golden Hoffman, they are the parents of three adult children: David, 29, Reuven, 27, and Ethan, 25.
Rabbi Scott Hoffman replaces Rabbi Deborah Silver, who leaves New Orleans on Mon., June 13.


