Masorti Leader Warns of Threats to Israeli Democracy
By NICHOLAS HAMBURGER, Special to the CCJN
Israel’s influential ultra-Orthodox contingency is threatening democracy in the country, Yizhar Hess, the chief executive of the Conservative Judaism movement in Israel, said at a talk on Wednesday, November 15 at Shir Chadash Conservative Synagogue in Metairie. In Israel, the Conservative movement is referred to as Masorti, which in Hebrew means “tradition.”
According to Hess, Jewish pluralism, or the free practice of various systems of Judaism, is currently at risk in Israel. Hess pointed to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s “tricky” freezing of an agreement last June that would have substantially improved the egalitarian prayer section of the Western Wall, also known as the Kotel.
Hess, who helped negotiate the Western Wall agreement with Netanyahu in January 2016, delivered an impassioned diatribe against the privileges Orthodox Judaism enjoys in Israel. “The unholy connection between religion and state in Israel has financial ramifications,” he said. “The Israeli government invests, every year, 3.7 billion shekels in Orthodox religious services and institutions.” 3.7 billion shekels is equal to roughly $1 billion. In comparison, Masorti and Reform combined receive a mere $200,000 from state funding, according to a New York Times article published in 2012.
In addition to the sizable financial backing Orthodox Judaism nets from the state, the Orthodox rabbinate wields significant control over marriage laws in Israel. Current law requires an Orthodox rabbi to oversee any marriage or divorce.
“If you marry outside of Israel – no matter how – it will be recognized in Israel when you enter the country,” Hess said. Despite this fact, the state does not recognize a Masorti or Reform union performed in Israel. “If Elvis Presley marries you in Las Vegas, it will be recognized by the state, but if Rabbi Silver marries you in Israel it will not be recognized. Can a Jewish state really accept this?” Hess asked, referring to Rabbi Deborah Silver of Shir Chadash.
Conservative is the second-most popular form of Judaism in the United States, after Reform. In Israel, however, only between 5 to 10 percent of the population identifies with Masorti or Reform. Masorti’s scarcity of state funding and exclusion from Israeli marriage laws, Hess suggested, contribute to its minority status.
“There are multiple opportunities for the Jewish Orthodox narrative to be manifested in Israel. It’s a challenge that’s more relevant than other challenges because it jeopardizes our ability to tell our story,” he said.
Hess became chief executive of Masorti in 2007 after a manifold career in the military, academia, and law. He served as a lieutenant in the Israeli Defense Forces before earning his bachelor’s degree in Political Science and Hebrew Studies. He is also a member of the Israeli Bar. He later went on to earn a master’s degree in Jewish Studies from the Schechter Institute and, hours before speaking at Shir Chadash, submitted his Ph.D. dissertation to Sussex University.
Speaking before a crowd of several dozen congregants, Hess concluded his remarks with a blunt repudiation of Israel’s ultra-Orthodox faction: “I think we have a decade that will determine if Israel will stay a country that we can be proud of, a vibrant democracy that balances nicely between Jewish values and democratic values, or, God forbid, a country that is taken over by Jewish fundamentalists.”


